Episode 74 - Julia Velkova
Throwaway Infrastructures: Dismantling Communication Networks
Theme: Infrastructures
Published: 5 November 2026
Summary
In this episode of SCAS Talks, media scholar Julia Velkova explores what happens when communication infrastructures reach the end of their lives. Drawing on her interdisciplinary research, she examines the dismantling of Sweden’s copper telephone network—a system that connected communities for more than a century and supported services beyond voice calls. Julia Velkova traces how decisions to replace legacy networks with newer technologies reflect changing market priorities and visions of the future. While newer services offer speed and capacity, their uneven coverage can leave rural and remote communities without reliable access, raising questions about universal connectivity and national sovereignty. The conversation also challenges research’s focus on how technologies emerge, urging attention to how they disappear and what their removal means. Julia Velkova connects this issue to the possible future ruins of today’s AI and data-center infrastructure.
Keywords
Infrastructure, copper networks, telecom engineering, universal access, interdisciplinarity
Suggested Link/s
About: Julia Velkova
Transcript of the Episode
Julia Velkova 00:08
Since those days in the mid 19th century, copper networks have expanded and endured through various kinds of shifts in geopolitics, social, technological, and environmental change. And they have, in most parts of the world where they have been maintained, they've reached the scale of covering entire nations. They have endured to the present, so that's more than a century. And from that perspective, they've been pretty resilient societally, socially resilient. They have endured through much more turbulent times than today. But what we have today, I think, it's this historical decision to decommission these networks and to disassemble them into their constituent elements, which is quite a novel idea to think in the sense of infrastructure as a throwaway infrastructure.
Natalie von der Lehr 01:05
Welcome to SCAS Talks, a podcast by the Swedish Collegium for Advanced Study. My name is Natalie von der Lehr, and in this episode I talk to Julia Velkova, professor of Media and Culture at Linköping University. She is a Pro Futura Scientia Fellow and was in residence at SCAS during the academic year of 2025/2026. Julia Velkova is a media scholar researching digital technologies and media infrastructures from interdisciplinary perspectives grounded in science and technology studies and anthropological approaches. In this episode, we will talk about some aspects of her project "When communication networks come to die, socio-cultural perspectives on infrastructural dismantling". And this is the fourth episode in our theme "Infrastructures". Welcome to SCAS Talks and the Studio.
Julia Velkova 01:58
Thank you.
Natalie von der Lehr 01:59
Very nice to have you here. Would you like to say a few more words about yourself?
Julia Velkova 02:04
I guess I'm slightly unusual bird in terms of academic trajectories, and perhaps the title of Professor of Media and Culture alludes to a rather linear path that one could imagine. Sometimes we talk about it like from daycare, kindergarten to a PhD, and then as if everything was predetermined. But for me, this was very much not the case. Partly on one hand, I have studied different things. My basic training is essentially in engineering, actually telecom engineering, and radio communications, and then I studied some philosophy, communications from more global perspectives, and then I got a PhD in media and communication studies. To after that spend five years in a department which was oriented to science and technology studies. So I carry all of these things with me in my research, and I never know what will be the next path. I also should mention that I've also not been always an academic. I came into academia quite late, actually, when I was 31. I decided to do a PhD. But before that, I used to work as a software developer, also in government in Bulgaria, in questions related to internet governance and internet policy. And when I moved to Sweden, I also worked in a theater as a theater producer. So all of these life experiences somehow, I guess, mix in what I do in various ways. And even though we can think of what I'm researching is a rather technical topic, these experiences reflect in various kind of methodologies, orientations, or questions that I ask.
Natalie von der Lehr 03:51
It sounds like you have a true interdisciplinary background.
Julia Velkova 03:55
I think so, and I think from my perspective today, I can just be extremely grateful to all the people along this way who saw a possibility to do something else, and recognize that even though I was maybe foreign to their field, we could be in conversation and open the door to me. So I'm now thinking very much about what kind of doors I could open for other people from within the position I am. And to promote interdisciplinarity, because I think it gives really interesting new angles to questions that we are exploring different perspectives that might be more surprising if we blend different forms of knowledge and different perspectives than if we just follow one path.
Natalie von der Lehr 04:43
Before we get into your research, I thought we could listen to a sound. Let's see what you think of this.
Natalie von der Lehr 05:05
What did we just hear?
Julia Velkova 05:07
Well, this was the sound of a modem, a device which we used in the 90s to connect to the internet. I think a lot of us, at least the generation that I am, and those who are older than me would remember this sound, because this was the first internet that we got as users was through modems. So we were very accustomed to to hear that sound. Today it's more of a nostalgic relic from a past, I guess. But yeah, for me, I experienced this sound I think first when I was maybe around 15 or 16, a teenager in Bulgaria, where I was raised and where I come from. And it was in many respects the sound of the future, like a hope, hopeful sound of sociality of all this period, the birth of the internet at the consumer level for the ordinary user to carry the promise that oh, we just can enter this other world and explore there and get lost in things. And I think also for me, as in the broader context, since I was then in Bulgaria, it was second half of the 90s. It was also the period of globalization. So, from my position there, we experienced this sound inseparable from globality and connection. But perhaps closer to the research topic for today or to our conversation, we should also mention that this sound was also reflecting a different way of organizing the internet when connecting to it meant to use older networks. The modem sounds as it is because it goes through the copper telephone lines, and the copper networks are these very old networks since the end of the 1800s telegraph signals, and after that they became retrofitted and developed further to support telephony, and so the internet in the beginning, in domestic spaces like our homes, was very much going through that. And that signal is very much the analog signal. We could hear the internet, and it was slow, and it was falling apart and disconnecting, and we were very frustrated.
Natalie von der Lehr 07:23
It took a long time to download things.
Julia Velkova 07:25
Yeah, yeah, very different from the age of streaming and the constant flow today.
Natalie von der Lehr 07:31
Shall we talk a little bit more specifically about your research then? What is your research about?
Julia Velkova 07:37
It's always difficult for me to to summarize things in in a few words, but I would say that I look at the social life of digital infrastructures and in communication networks. And I'm asking questions like, how are these networks imagined and made by people and others, humans and non-humans, or more than humans, in different times and places. How are they imagined? How do they endure over time? And whose work and energy powers them? Who do they work for? Whom do they exclude? What values do they promote? How people form relationships with these technologies and networks? And more recently, I started thinking more about questions about also how these networks reach an end and come to die, which is the focus of my Pro Futura project. I guess my interest in like gliding from these questions on how networks like the landline or the internet or digital networks made of digital technologies, entities like data centers, like satellites, ground stations, algorithms, all of these together - I mean, they enable what we started from. They enable connection. They enable belonging. They're sites of effect, of relationships that people have with each other, but also through these networks. And I used to be interested mostly in digital technologies, and probably this speaks kind of a generational bias. But I really got fascinated with questions of the landlines and copper landlines as they're going away today. In Sweden, we have already put an end to the copper network, almost an end this year. 2026, in November, the last subscribers will be kicked out of the network. But this is a process that has been going on for 20 years. But also, 2026 is remarkable in the sense also that the European Commission has mandated that all the countries in Europe, from now on, in the next eight years, must decommission their landline networks in order to make a future, in order to make a path for networks that are supporting more data-intensive and compute-intensive services that are and data traffic that are regarded as necessary in terms of enabling technologies like chatbots that work for different kind of large language models and data exchange between them, which go under the umbrella term of AI. So for me, I thought the idea to dismantle entire nationwide networks in order to make the path for an imagined future that is not yet here, but it's supposed to be coming because we dismantle something that is working was very uncunning. I found the copper network particularly interesting because these networks have existed, as I mentioned earlier, since the mid 19th century. They've been continuously retrofitted, maintained, and expanded since times of the British Empire, and in fact they were central for building and maintaining power and exchange of information between the different parts of the British Empire. Something that basically gave rise to global communications. But our current infrastructure today is still following on the same pathway, so we still lay fiber optic cables on the same pathways as the copper networks, which is quite remarkable. But I should say, of course, also that since those days in the mid 19th century, copper networks have expanded and endured through various kinds of shifts in geopolitics, social, technological, and environmental change, and they have, in most parts of the world where they have been maintained and they've been, well, they've reached the scale of covering entire nations, they have endured to the present, so that's more than a century. And from that perspective, they've been pretty resilient societally, socially resilient. They have endured through much more turbulent times than today. But what we have today, I think, it's this historical decision to decommission these networks and to disassemble them into their constituent elements, which is quite a novel idea to think in the sense of infrastructure as a throwaway infrastructure. Like we we can just put it apart and throw it away when it has been wiring entire nations and fires and all sort of things. So my interest in this topic was partly this conundrum of like how to understand this new condition, how to understand why is this happening, how to think about the end of life of communication networks, but also as a corrective to dominant perspectives in research across various fields, media and communication studies, but also science and technology studies, history of technology, which have generally had a very substantial orientation towards emergence. So we know the histories of the internet, the post, the print, as histories of emergence. How these technologies emerged, how they evolved, what happened, what kind of questions did they bring. And in a certain sense, our vocabulary, conceptual vocabulary to think about these infrastructures, derives from these orientations towards emergence. So I think that the process, ongoing process of end of life of copper networks and their physical dismantling, offers an opportunity to correct these histories and to really zoom into the politics and decisions of how these enduring, long enduring networks that have spanned and maintained, kept together societies are falling apart, and from there to try to develop hopefully new vocabularies for how we form relations to technology. When I was presenting some of this work at a conference of historians of technology, I got a comment that oh, this is - my research is about writing the other half of the history of infrastructure. We've written only the first half on how it came about. Now we need to write the second half, how it disappears. And I never thought really of my research as historical, but I do think that it has relevance indeed to opening up also new kind of perspectives in fields outside of media studies, and probably also more historical perspectives on revisiting our knowledge of infrastructures, not only how they emerged, but also how they came to disappear before they become ruins.
Natalie von der Lehr 14:22
Why would you want to dismantle something that is perfectly working and that has been around, as you said, since the mid 19th century, pretty much globally? Something that is working perfectly fine and has served us. Why take this away?
Julia Velkova 14:39
This is an excellent question, and I have been working in my research with primarily understanding this in the context of Sweden, and I'm currently expanding to understand what does it mean at the European level as well. But in the context of Sweden, in 2005 there was a very severe storm in Sweden, the Gudrun storm. Which destroyed vast arrays of forests, and it also destroyed vast areas of the network of the copper network in the southern part of Sweden. This was a moment when the organization decided to rethink instead of restoring and repairing, which it has always done for more than a century, to try to reimagine its own future without this network. And back to your question, why would you want to dismantle something that is working? It depends who you ask, right? From the perspective of the owner of the network, this has been, I would say, in my research so far, I've found out that this has been a decision of getting to terms with a new role and a new form of organization that is not oriented anymore towards the public and the creating maintaining a public value of universal connection, but is forced, put into this market logic where it needs to operate towards profitability and economic growth, and then it just needs to create new markets. So this was perhaps a very radical decision to dismantle the network, but it has been the start of it, I would say. So, the starting was to remove a market that was considered not part of the future. This dismantling is very much a future-making process in that sense. I think that the question here is that is interesting to bring about is the tremendous amount of power that such decisions and actors have on reorganizing the entire communications of an entire nation, because at the same time as Telia decided to dismantle the network, I mean this has partly been an uncertain process as well. Nobody knew how this will play out. There was no mobile phone network in place, so I mean, everything was about building new and removing the old, and discovering how to do it. So this process has been going on for more than 20 years now, but it's coming to an end. And during this period, we did get in many places in Sweden mobile connectivity. We didn't get fiber optics, but we also lost the copper network, and this has been a very difficult process, both internally for the organization and for the people who were affected along this path. So it's been a collective move and detachment, both inside and outside. So I would say that like endings, like the decision to dismantle something, casts things in uncertainty. We might think from the present that they knew what they're doing, or like we know, but it's a discovery part of making the future. But a very radical decision, which I think the major issue with it is perhaps the biggest issue is the loss of universal access in Sweden, the country which for 120 years at least has been the country with the largest number of telephones per capita. And then I should also say the telephonies and the copper networks have sustained not only domestic telephone, as we know, but also home alarms, flight services. There's things non humans connected to these networks, and how are they negotiating dismantling is also a question which is not very clear. What are we losing there? Yeah, but so why would you want to dismantle something that is working. It could be to make a future, but by making this future, you are putting an ending to a lot of things, and it's a difficult and laborious process that a lot of actors have to live through and negotiate, and yeah, and come over. It's quite a bet on the future.
Natalie von der Lehr 18:43
I would say this is risky business, right? Is there any chance that we might regret this? Any risk, maybe I should say, that we might regret this later on?
Julia Velkova 18:53
It's hard to say right now because of this uncertainty that endings bring, right? What we see in Sweden, for instance, and a point of regret or not could be that as we lose public universal access to copper network, what did we gain? Well, we gained in cities we have excellent mobile connectivity. We have high-speed internet. We are all streaming and consuming large amounts of data and so on. But in parts of cities, in rural areas, and especially in northern parts of the country, we have dead zones. We have areas with patchy connections that will never be of interest to market actors like Telia or Tele2 or whoever else, and where we have new actors such as Starlink assuming the role of public utility. And I think that this is worth thinking in a time when there's a discussion about sovereignty, and we should have because of changes in geopolitics, there's a turn to having more sovereign infrastructure and nation-owned infrastructure. And so I think here in this context, to have an actor like Starlink providing connectivity is really not the imagined path of how sovereignty is done. We have had sovereignty through these networks that we are now losing, or we have lost in Sweden already, but the rest of Europe will lose in the coming eight years. So this is perhaps one thing that might be regretted. It's not about the service or the speed at consumer level, but it's a different value. What have we cast in disrepair, dismantling, in a changed time. Because one should also say that in Sweden, the decision to dismantle the the copper network came in a completely different geopolitical situation and time. It was in the aftermath of the financial crisis when new markets, new jobs, new everything was very much in the demand. It was not in the context of war and political, geopolitical instability. So, how will this play out further? We don't know.
Natalie von der Lehr 21:03
I think I will think differently now about infrastructures after hearing you talking about this, and also start to think about what is next when the now existing things disappear, which they will, if, when I listen to you, I believe that. Then what is next, and how will that change our lives and our behavior?
Julia Velkova 21:24
I think that's a timely question to ask in the looming anticipations of the AI balloon bust. So, if and when the bubble around AI bursts, what we'll get is all the ruins of the data centers and the computation infrastructure that was built in idea of a future that might just not come to fruition. So then we'll have other questions to ask: Who is going to care about these ruins, the AI ruins? What kind of form and shape will they take? What will we do with them? That's a very topical question, actually, this year, which is already discussed by scholars and speculating: what could that be in a time that is, we are living before or anticipating the ruins now of AI?
Natalie von der Lehr 22:13
So, sort of already thinking about the the past of the future.
Julia Velkova 22:16
Yes, yes,
Natalie von der Lehr 22:17
That sounds very interesting. An interesting thought experiment. You are a Pro Futura Scientia Fellow and were in residence at SCAS during the academic year of 2025/2026. What was your experience of the multi- and interdisciplinary research environment here at the Collegium?
Julia Velkova 22:43
Well, in many respects, it's been amazing and very enriching. I should say that as a Pro Futura fellow, my relation and connection with SCAS is much longer than this year in residence. So, I started my Pro Futura project in 2023, and I'm halfway through. It's a five-year program, so I think in the scope of the Pro Futura Fellowship itself, what I've found really amazing, and I really appreciated the work that SCAS did and facilitated, was in organizing an amazing leadership course, and providing the opportunity to us as fellows, Pro Futura, to take it because this has been completely transforming, in many ways, my experience and work. And in general, I think the Pro Futura program has been just transformative and opening many different worlds that I didn't know existed in academia, which I think the residents this year just reinforced and made more obvious. So, for instance, I learned about the network of Institutes for Advanced Study because last year we celebrated the 40-year anniversary of SCAS, and for me, the fact that there was such a network was a mystery, but it really opened a new way of thinking about the arenas and places where scholarship is done and can be done in Europe and internationally. I mean, also at like everyday level, the meeting with all the smart scholars here in residence at SCAS simultaneously has been just a world-opening experience. And I mean I have made a lot of friends from other fields, but I also learned a lot about how other disciplines and universities are organized and what are their concerns at the moment. And it's been also wonderful just to meet all the staff at SCAS and to see who is doing all the invisible work of running this organization and doing the lunches, making everything flow and smooth, and I mean, again, to get perhaps an infrastructural perspective on SCAS and how things are assembled into into being. that.
Natalie von der Lehr 24:57
Thank you very much for joining me here in the studio. And our listeners, of course.
Julia Velkova 25:01
Thank you for all the wonderful questions and the time.
Natalie von der Lehr 25:09
And thank you for listening to SCAS Talks, a podcast by the Swedish Collegium for Advanced Study. In this episode, I have talked to Julia Velkova, professor of media and culture at Linköping University and Pro Futura Scientia Fellow. She was in residence at SCAS during the academic year of 2025/2026. We have talked about her research on the end of infrastructures, especially the copper network in Sweden. And this was the fourth episode within our theme infrastructures. The previous episodes in this theme include: "Banking before banks, credit and debt in pre-industrial France" with Elise Dermineur Reuterswärd; "Infrastructures, habitats, and slum lives" with Ash Amin; and "Black Earth, White Bread, a technopolitical history of Russian agriculture and food" with Susanne Wengle. These are episodes 23, 26, and 39, respectively. SCAS Talks features a broad variety of topics, which is a reflection of the multi- and interdisciplinary research environment at the Collegium. We are sure that there is something of interest for everyone. Tune in, find your favorite topic, or surprise yourself with something new. And as always, we are very happy if you can recommend SCAS Talks to your colleagues and friends. SCAS Talks is available on Podbean, Apple Podcast, Spotify, and most podcast apps. I would like to thank Julia Velkova once again for talking to me, and thanks to you for listening. Bye for now.
Transcribed by https://otter.ai
